What Cheese To Use for Grilled Cheese? Perfect Grilled Cheese Sandwich

american cheese slices

A grilled cheese sandwich is a classic comfort food that never goes out of style. Do you want to know the secret to making a perfect grilled cheese sandwich? Breaking news: you need the right cheese! Don’t just settle for any old cheese.

So, what cheese to use for grilled cheese? Cheddar and American cheeses are great for a classic grilled cheese sandwich because they melt well and have mild flavors. 

In this article, we’ll explain why you need to get the right cheese for your grilled sandwich. Follow along as we explore what types of cheese make the best grilled cheese sandwiches and why it matters. 

Get ready to find out why you need that perfect cheese and how to get it!

The Importance of Cheese for Grilled Cheese Sandwich

The grilled cheese sandwich is a staple in American cuisine and is loved by people of all ages. While bread and cheese may seem like simple ingredients, the type of cheese used in the sandwich plays a critical role in determining the flavor, texture, and overall appeal of the dish.

Cheese is the star of a grilled cheese sandwich. It gives the sandwich a flavor that is rich, creamy, and indulgent that you can’t get from any other ingredient. Different cheeses have different melting points, flavor profiles, and textures, and it is essential to choose the right cheese for your grilled cheese to ensure that it turns out perfectly every time.

For example, sharp cheddar cheese is often used in grilled cheese sandwiches because it has a strong, tangy taste that goes well with the bread. Swiss cheese, on the other hand, is milder in flavor and provides a more delicate flavor profile that works well with more delicate toppings, such as sliced tomato or avocado.

When choosing cheese for your grilled cheese sandwich, it’s important to consider the melting point of the cheese. A cheese with a low melting point will melt quickly and easily, while a cheese with a high melting point may not melt as well, resulting in a sandwich that is greasy and messy.

What Cheese To Use for Grilled Cheese?

1. Cheddar Cheese

cheddar cheese

Cheddar cheese is a sharp, tangy cheese that is a popular choice for grilled cheese sandwiches. It has a strong flavor profile that works well with a variety of toppings and is known for its ability to melt smoothly and evenly, making it an excellent choice for grilled cheese.

2. Swiss Cheese

swiss cheese

Swiss cheese is a milder cheese that has a creamy and nutty flavor. It is a great choice for grilled cheese sandwiches, as it provides a delicate flavor profile that works well with more delicate toppings such as tomato or avocado. Swiss cheese is also known for its ability to melt evenly, making it a great option for a perfectly melted sandwich.

3. Brie Cheese

brie cheese

Brie cheese is a soft, creamy cheese that has a mild, slightly nutty flavor. It is a popular choice for grilled cheese sandwiches due to its rich and indulgent flavor, but it can be messy to work with as it has a high moisture content and can be difficult to melt evenly.

4. Gouda Cheese

gouda cheese

Gouda cheese is a semi-hard cheese that has a nutty, slightly sweet flavor. It is a versatile cheese that works well in grilled cheese sandwiches and is known for its ability to melt smoothly and evenly.

5. American Cheese

american cheese slices

American cheese is a processed cheese that is known for its smooth texture and mild flavor. It is a popular choice for grilled cheese sandwiches as it melts evenly and is easy to work with.

Tips for Making the Perfect Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Use the Right Bread

Choosing the right bread is essential to making a great grilled cheese sandwich. Look for bread that is sturdy enough to hold up to the cheese and toppings but soft enough to become crispy when toasted. Some popular bread choices for grilled cheese include sourdough, whole wheat, or rye bread.

Butter Both Sides

To ensure that your grilled cheese sandwich is evenly toasted and crispy, it’s important to butter both sides of the bread before cooking. This will also help the bread turn golden brown and add a rich, buttery flavor.

Cook on Low Heat

Cooking your grilled cheese sandwich on low heat will give you more control over the cooking process and ensure that the cheese has time to melt evenly without burning the bread. High heat will cause the bread to become too crispy before the cheese has a chance to melt.

Don’t Overstuff the Sandwich

While it may be tempting to add as many toppings as possible, overstuffing your grilled cheese sandwich can cause it to become bulky and difficult to handle. Stick to a few important toppings and ingredients that go well with the cheese.

Experiment with Different Cheeses and Toppings

The great thing about grilled cheese is that there are endless possibilities when it comes to cheese and topping combinations. Experiment with different types of cheese and toppings to find your perfect grilled cheese combination.

Why Won’t My Cheese Melt in Grilled Cheese?

This is a common question asked by many people who are trying to perfect the art of making a delicious grilled cheese sandwich. While it may seem like a simple task, getting the right combination of cheese and bread is crucial for creating the perfect grilled cheese. If you have ever experienced the frustration of having cheese that won’t melt in your grilled cheese, then this guide is for you.

One of the main reasons why cheese won’t melt in grilled cheese is because the slices are too thick. When the cheese is too thick, the cheese-to-bread ratio is off, and the cheese won’t melt perfectly all the way through. If you use too thick slices, the sandwich will be more bread than cheese, detracting from the overall flavor and texture of the grilled cheese.

On the other hand, if the cheese slices are too thin, then the sandwich won’t hold up. The cheese won’t have enough support to keep the sandwich together, and the cheese will simply slip out of the sandwich as you take a bite. To make the perfect grilled cheese, you need to find the right amount of cheese and bread.

One solution to this problem is to use plain white bread for a classic grilled cheese. Melted cheese goes well with white bread, and the bread won’t take away from the taste of the cheese. If you are looking for something a little more gourmet, then try using jalapeno cheddar sourdough bread. This bread has a delicious flavor and texture that will add a little extra oomph to your grilled cheese.

Why Won’t My Grilled Cheese Get Crispy?

This is a common question asked by many people who are looking to perfect the art of making a delicious grilled cheese sandwich. A crispy grilled cheese sandwich is one of life’s simple pleasures, but getting it right can be a challenge. 

For the best results, toasting your bread first is key. You can achieve the desired golden edges and luscious crisp on your bread by giving it a quick toast. It will also help prevent the bread from getting soggy, no matter how many fillings you add. Toasting the bread before grilling will also help to reduce the moisture content of the bread, allowing it to cook faster and get crispy more easily.

Another factor that may be contributing to your grilled cheese not getting crispy is the type of bread you are using. Some types of bread, like Wonder Bread, are designed to be soft and fluffy, which can make it difficult to get a crispy texture. Consider using a type of bread that is designed to be crisp, like sourdough or ciabatta, for the best results.

It’s also important to consider the temperature at which you are cooking your grilled cheese. If the temperature is too low, the cheese won’t melt, and if the temperature is too high, the cheese will melt too quickly, leaving you with a soggy sandwich. Experimenting with different temperatures until you find the sweet spot is key to getting a crispy grilled cheese.

Finally, the amount of cheese you use can also have an impact on the crispiness of your grilled cheese. Too much cheese can result in a heavy and soggy sandwich, while too little cheese won’t give you the creamy, melted center that you are after. Experiment with different cheese-to-bread ratios until you find the perfect balance.


In conclusion, grilled cheese is a classic comfort food that is easy to make and delicious to eat. The type of cheese you use is crucial to the flavor and texture of the sandwich, so it’s important to choose the right one for your taste preferences. Whether you prefer a creamy brie, a sharp cheddar, or a tangy goat cheese, there’s a cheese out there that’s perfect for your grilled cheese sandwich. 

Remember to use the right bread, cook on low heat, and don’t overstuff the sandwich to ensure that your grilled cheese turns out perfectly every time. With these tips and a little experimentation, you can create a grilled cheese sandwich that is truly unforgettable.

Similar Posts